President Roy McDiarmid called the meeting to order at 10:00
a.m. in the Waldo Schmitt Room, National Museum of Natural History,
Washington, D.C. Council members and editorial staff present:
Michael Carleton, Marilyn Schotte, Jeffrey Williams, and Neal
Woodman (Elected Council); Ron Heyer (President Elect); Chad Walter
(Treasurer); Carole Baldwin (Secretary); Richard Banks (Editor
and Past President); Bruce Collette, Leslie Knapp, and David
Pawson (Past Presidents); and Steve Gardiner (Associate Editor).
Minutes of the 131st Annual Meeting, published in Volume 117(4)
of the Proceedings, were approved. President McDiarmid
then summarized recent Society activities, noting that during
2005 there had been a Council meeting on February 22 and a meeting
of certain elected Council on August 10.
President McDiarmid then called on Chad Walter for the Treasurer's
Report (Table 1). Income for the period 1 January 2004 to 31 December
2004 was $81,820.66, and expenses for the same period were $74,153.68.
Total Society assets as of 15 April 2005 were $116,620.11. After
fluctuating monthly during the year, the Society's endowment fund
showed an increase of $5,946.46 at the end of 2004, which includes
$350.00 in donations by Society members. Walter noted that the
Society continues to bear the financial burden of waiving charges
for more billable Proceedings pages than the recommended
20% per volume; for Volume 117, the Society waived approximately
25% of page charges to authors. Prior to the meeting, Council
member Neal Woodman and past President Don Wilson submitted a
statement to President McDiarmid indicating that they had reviewed
the financial statements and accountings of the Treasurer and
were satisfied with their findings. The Treasurer's report was
approved.
Proceedings Editor Richard Banks reported that Issues
117(3) and 117(4) were published in December, 2004, and Issues
118(1) and 118(2) were published in April, 2005, and June, 2005,
respectively. Those issues comprised 69 papers and 857 pages.
Issue 118(1) was a memorial issue dedicated to Brian Kensley,
deceased past President of the Society. Issue 118(3) will be published
in September, 2005, and 118(4) in December. There is no backlog
of papers awaiting publication, and the most important factor
determining speed of publication is turnaround time by the Associate
Editors and authors. Banks noted that submissions are down from
2004 -- 47 at the end of July, 2004, 28 at the end of July, 2005.
Regarding the large number of free pages the Society publishes
each year, Banks indicated that he is estimating page charges
when he receives a manuscript and is including this estimate in
his letter to authors that acknowledges manuscript receipt. In
efforts to minimize the number of free pages published per volume,
Banks queues the papers for publication based on authors' ability
to pay page charges. It was suggested at the August 10, 2005,
meeting of selected Council that the Editor also try being more
insistent in his communications with authors regarding the paying
of pages charges.
Banks then noted that the Society has been approached about
publishing several new Bulletins. The Council unanimously approved
a bulletin entitled Terrestrial Vertebrates of the Guiana Shield,
which is being paid for by Vicki Funk's Biodiversity of the Guiana
Shield Project and should be published in the fall of 2005; a
Bulletin on the vascular plants of Plummers Island, by Stan Shetler,
which is being paid for by the Washington Biologists' Field Club
and also may be out in 2005; and, assuming private funding is
available as stated by the author, Clyde Roper, the first part
of a 3-part series on the cephalopods of the Indian Ocean. Considerable
discussion ensued regarding a fourth proposed Bulletin a
multi-authored compilation on the biodiversity of Gabon. Because
no Society editorial staff was involved with the reviews of the
manuscripts to be included (16 papers in English and in French),
the Council was hesitant to approve the content for publication
as a Society Bulletin. A majority of the Council approved a motion
to allow Banks to request the reviews of the papers and to have
them reviewed by the Publications Committee (Ron Heyer, Michael
Carleton, and Neal Woodman). Following this review, acceptance
of the Bulletin will be voted upon by the Council. This Bulletin
is scheduled to be published and paid for by The Smithsonian Institution's
Monitoring and Assessment of Biodiversity Program. President McDiarmid
concluded this discussion by acknowledging that the Society needs
a process for dealing with future Bulletins and that he would
draft a set of guidelines that outline a proposed process.
One change to the Proceedings editorial staff was announced:
Dan Nicholson has replaced Ted Bayer as the Classical Languages
Editor. Banks thanked all of the Associate Editors and credited
the quality of the journal to their hard work. He was particularly
grateful for Christopher Boyko's efforts on the Kensley Memorial
Issue. President McDiarmid then reminded the Council that Dick
Banks is serving as the acting Editor and that the Society needs
to locate a replacement as soon as possible. Past President Bruce
Collette presented a motion on behalf of the Society formerly
thanking Banks for taking over when the Society needed an Editor
and for handling the complicated issues related to the publication
of Bulletins. The motion was unanimously approved.
On behalf of Custodian of Publications, Storrs Olson, McDiarmid
reported little activity in the sales of publications. The Society
sold twelve copies of Bulletin 11, which is significant in light
of the large number of copies of that Bulletin distributed by
the authors (Springer and Johnson). Society web-page developer,
Steve Gardiner, noted that he would add information regarding
the availability of Bulletins to the website.
Secretary Baldwin read a report submitted prior to the meeting
by the Finance Committee, which comprises Stephen Cairns, Frank
Ferrari, Chad Walter, and Richard Banks. The Committee met on
11 March 2005 and noted a modest increase in the Endowment Fund
due to appreciation and an increase of about $3,000 from gifts
to the Endowment Fund, a new means of increasing the Society's
funds initiated in 2004. The Committee discussed and endorsed
the policy of providing authors PDF (Portable Document Format)
files in lieu of reprints, with the PDF files being sold at approximately
the cost of 100 reprints. Treasurer Walter noted that the Society
is receiving requests from authors for PDF files as well as reprints.
The Committee also discussed the possibility of raising dues and
subscription rates for the Proceedings, but decided to
delay any increases. The Committee concluded that it is satisfied
with the status of the finances of the Society. President McDiarmid
suggested that the Committee may want to consider any future changes
in dues in the context of the Society's future decisions regarding
electronic publishing of the Proceedings. He then called
for a vote on the Finance- Committee report, which was approved.
McDiarmid called on Steve Gardiner to provide an update of the Society's request to have the Proceedings included in the BioOne database collection. Gardiner stated that he had received a letter from the Director of Business Development at BioOne indicating that the company was not accepting new journal titles until it completes a review of all of its holdings and examines its strategy for adding new ones. BioOne will then contact interested publishers. Gardiner emphasized that he believes electronic publishing is critical for the future health of the journal. He also suggested the Society consider converting to a larger page format, which would be better for the type of material we publish, especially figures. Jon Norenberg suggested that we consider converting entirely to electronic publishing. McDiarmid questioned the Society's goals: Do we want to publish hard and electronic copies of the Proceedings? He then appointed Steve Gardiner, Stephen Cairns, and Jon Norenberg as members of a new Electronic Publishing Committee and charged them with investigating the
Society's options, including the idea of going fully electronic.
President McDiarmid concluded the meeting by reminding the attendees
to submit names to be considered for the position of Editor and
for members of a Membership Committee, a currently defunct committee
but one required by the Constitution. The meeting was adjourned
at 11:45 a.m.
Respectfully submitted,
Carole C. Baldwin
Secretary